Design Patterns Revisited
نویسنده
چکیده
Design patterns are general solutions for recurring problems and used to develop flexible, reusable and modular software with Object-Oriented Programming (OOP). Prior studies have shown a lack of modularity in object-oriented design patterns. AspectOriented Programming (AOP) aims at improving flexibility, reusability, and modularity in object-oriented designs. In a case study Hannemann and Kiczales have argued that AOP improves the implementation of GoF design patterns. Feature-Oriented Programming (FOP) is a new programming technique that also aims to improve the modularity in object-oriented designs. In this paper we compare OOP, AOP, and FOP in a quantiative case study of design pattern implementations. We evaluate the OOP, AOP, and FOP design pattern implementations with respect to modularity and show that FOP performs best compared to OOP and AOP.
منابع مشابه
Cross-Linguistic Transfer Revisited: The Case of English and Persian
The present study sought to investigate the evidence for cross-linguistic transfer in a partial English immersion and non-immersion educational setting. To this end, a total of 145 first, third and fifth graders in a partial English immersion program and 95 students from the same grade levels in a non-immersion program were chosen. Six different English and Persian tests were administered: the ...
متن کاملImpedance Control of Robots Using Voltage Control Strategy Revisited
In this note, we show that the impedance control strategy proposed in the paper is not feasible from practical implementation point of view. Next, a robust impedance controller is proposed for electrically driven robots using Fourier series (FS). The fact that robots' actuators have limited voltage is also considered in controller design procedure. In comparison with other impedance controllers...
متن کاملQUICKSELECT Revisited
We give an overview of the running time analysis of the random divide-and-conquer algorithm FIND or QUICKSELECT. The results concern moments, distribution of FIND’s running time, the limiting distribution, a stochastic bound and the key: a stochastic fixed point equation.
متن کاملDesign Patterns and Aspects – Modular Designs with Seamless Run-Time Integration
Some solutions proposed in the original design pattern literature were shaped by techniques as well as language deficiencies from object-oriented software development. However, new modularity constructs, composition and transformation mechanisms offered by aspect-oriented programming address deficiencies of object-oriented modeling. This suggests classical design pattern solutions to be revisit...
متن کاملThe function ring functors of pointfree topology revisited
This paper establishes two new connections between the familiar function ring functor ${mathfrak R}$ on the category ${bf CRFrm}$ of completely regular frames and the category {bf CR}${mathbf sigma}${bf Frm} of completely regular $sigma$-frames as well as their counterparts for the analogous functor ${mathfrak Z}$ on the category {bf ODFrm} of 0-dimensional frames, given by the integer-valued f...
متن کامل